1. To explain to many of my non-religious Jewish brethren what is happening in the world, one must first understand a basic principle of Torah history: the world operates in cycles.
2. Just as there is wind, rain, heat, and cold—natural systems embedded into creation—there are also spiritual systems embedded into history.
3. When the Jewish people left Egypt and stood at Mount Sinai, something entirely new entered human history: the creation of a nation whose purpose was not merely survival, politics, or land, but elevation—a nation tasked with carrying Divine consciousness into the world.
4. That calling demands maintenance. A Jew cannot remain spiritually elevated by inheritance alone. It requires Torah, awareness, discipline, and responsibility toward fellow Jews and toward humanity itself.
5. But history reveals a repeated pattern: when Jews grow weary of that burden, when comfort, acceptance, and worldly desire begin to outweigh covenantal duty, substitutes emerge—new ideologies, new loyalties, new gods.
5A. Alongside the giving of Torah and the elevation of man, there was also the creation and empowerment of the evil inclination—the inner force that pulls a person toward self-interest, appetite, ego, and rebellion. This was not a flaw in creation, but part of the design itself. Without the possibility of choosing wrong, there is no meaning in choosing right. Free choice is the engine of human purpose. A person stands constantly between construction and destruction, truth and illusion, discipline and indulgence. The purpose of this world is to choose correctly, refine oneself, elevate oneself, and through that refinement merit the World to Come and the higher spiritual state for which man was created.
6. Those gods are not always carved from stone. Sometimes they are the idols of ego, politics, comfort, social approval, and modernity itself.
7. This is not new. It happened in the days of the prophets, in the era of the Second Temple, in the age of Hellenistic assimilation, in Europe, and now again in our generation.
8. When enough Jews drift from Torah, another cycle awakens: the hatred of Jews intensifies.
9. This is one of the hardest truths for the secular Jew to grasp. Antisemitism is not merely political, economic, or social. Those are its garments; the root runs deeper.
10. Torah teaches that exile has a structure, and within that structure the nations often become instruments of pressure against Israel when Israel loses its center.
11. Just as storms gather under certain atmospheric conditions, hatred of Jews gathers under certain spiritual conditions.
12. When Jews forget who they are, the nations remind them—often harshly, often violently, and often without understanding why they themselves are driven by it.
13. A Jew may call himself secular, Reform, Conservative, cultural, or simply Jewish by heritage, but Torah’s claim is ancient and uncompromising: Jewish identity detached from Torah cannot sustain itself indefinitely.
14. A Jew may run from Torah, assimilate, intermarry, or reconstruct Judaism into something more comfortable, but history has shown that the Jewish name without the Jewish covenant weakens across generations.
15. Then comes the reminder.
16. That reminder may come through exile, social pressure, hostility, or antisemitism—not because the nations invented this role, but because in Divine history they often serve as the mechanism of awakening.
17. It is like a restrained wild dog on a leash: when Israel is aligned, the leash holds tight; when Israel strays, the leash loosens.
18. The nations bark louder. Sometimes they bite.
19. This pattern has repeated for more than 2,500 years—from the Babylonian captivity to the Roman destruction of Jerusalem, from medieval expulsions to modern Europe.
20. The mercy of God is not only in blessing. Sometimes His mercy is in refusing to allow a Jew to disappear completely into history.
21. The message is constant: You belong to Me—even when you try to forget.
22. Even when a Jew rebuilds identity without covenant, even when Judaism is reduced to culture or ethnicity alone, history rises to challenge that illusion.
23. The world does not allow the Jew to forget. That itself is part of Divine mercy.
24. The final redemption, according to Torah, is not merely political sovereignty, military strength, or even the existence of the State of Israel.
25. Redemption is return—return to Torah, return to covenant, and return to responsibility.
26. And when that return reaches its fullness, the barking dog of antisemitism will no longer be needed.
27. The leash will tighten, the nations will settle, and peace will come.

Summary:

The Broken Family and the Long Exile
The love Jews have for one another has always been both our greatest strength and our greatest challenge.
A large family can live under one roof even when every sibling is different. One child may be intellectual, another emotional, another ambitious, another quiet. They may have different interests, personalities, talents, and directions in life. Yet the family survives because there is a father, a mother, and a structure that holds the home together.
But when one sibling no longer wants the rules of the family, tension begins. Another follows. Then another. Soon the unity of the house weakens. What once was one home becomes divided rooms, competing visions, resentment, ego, and chaos.
This is, in many ways, the story of Jewish history.
We began together. We traveled together. We received the Torah together. But over time, desires, philosophies, politics, ego, comfort, and outside influence pulled different groups in different directions.
Then came destruction.
The First Temple was destroyed.
The Second Temple was destroyed.
Exile scattered the family into fragments across the world.
And even inside exile, the fragmentation continued. Communities split further and further apart. Some disappeared completely.
The Marrano Jews of Spain were crushed under Catholic pressure and assimilation. Entire Jewish worlds in Eastern Europe were later shattered by Communism, poverty, war, and modern secular movements.
When emancipation arrived in Europe and Jews were finally allowed into universities, finance, science, and public life, many rose rapidly in influence and success. Jews became enormously impactful in 19th- and early 20th-century Europe.
Very few people even know that the company Mercedes-Benz traces its name to Mercedes, the daughter of Emil Jellinek, a wealthy Jew deeply involved in financing and promoting the automobile enterprise under the condition that the car bear his daughter’s name.
The Jews flourished when doors opened.
But freedom also created a new challenge.
Many children of that modern world no longer wanted the “old house.” They no longer wanted the discipline, boundaries, or responsibilities of Torah life. Some stayed connected culturally. Others drifted entirely.
Yet the Torah-observant Jews continued forward generation after generation, preserving the structure of the home even while scattered across continents.
Whether one accepts that view or not, traditional Judaism sees history through this lens: the nations of the world ultimately push the Jew back toward the house he came from.
Not necessarily through politics or even through the State of Israel.
Sometimes through loneliness.
Sometimes through pressure.
Sometimes through the realization that success without belonging leaves emptiness.
And sometimes through something very simple: a warm Shabbos table in Brooklyn, Baltimore, Lakewood, or anywhere else where a Jewish family opens its home and reminds another Jew that he still belongs to the family.

Posted in

Leave a comment