In tight-knit communities, especially in times without external structure — like school breaks or public holidays — a powerful social gravity forms. Those without strong inner direction feel compelled to follow the crowd: same vacations, same coats, same patterns of behavior. Not out of pride. But out of fear — fear of being excluded. And so, they become sheep.

But why?

Because they lack structure. They have no internal scaffolding, no framework of thought and value built around truth. A person who has a fixed schedule of morning and night learning, a committed seder, and is particular about davening with a minyan three times a day — such a person has spiritual discipline. He becomes structured from the inside out. And when you are structured, it’s very difficult to become a sheep. You won’t be pulled off course just because someone else is. But a person who has no set rhythm — or can easily break his own routine — becomes vulnerable. He drifts. And so they chase shadows — belonging, trends, approval — instead of rooting themselves in the truths Hashem embedded within them.

This insight is beautifully laid out in the foundational work Chovot HaLevavot (“Duties of the Heart”). It teaches that to fulfill the aim of the intellectual soul, man must align with what the Creator has planted in his mind:

A. The Creator’s Imprint: Insights from Chovot HaLevavot

> “These are the means by which a man can realize the aim of the intellectual stimulus: he should have a clear grasp of what the Creator has implanted in the human mind; namely, adoration of the truth, and contempt for falsehood; preference for righteousness, and avoidance of injustice.”

These are not theoretical ideals. They are a roadmap to clarity:

Rewarding kindness appropriately

Condemning wickedness without compromise

Maintaining peace with others

Acting with sincere kindness

Evaluating severity and consequences of deeds fairly

Offering forgiveness when sincere repentance occurs

These duties of the heart are spiritual structures. They root a person internally. And when one lacks them, he will instead borrow his values from what others are doing — creating an identity of imitation, not authenticity.

This lack of internal moral compass stems from confusion between the vertical and horizontal planes of existence. When a person does not understand the vertical — that is, the soul’s direct connection to Hashem, above time, society, and status — he seeks structure and validation horizontally, from the world around him. Instead of serving the Eternal, he ends up serving the temporary: fashion, comparison, and fear.

Without a clear vertical orientation, the horizontal becomes king — and the soul becomes a servant not to G-d, but to public perception.

B. The Power of Perception and Internal Alignment

When a man establishes these divine concepts clearly in his soul, his mind becomes sound, and his perception sharpens.

Then, if G-d awakens him, he will:

Feel the stirring of soul and intellect

Begin to recognize the abundant favors in his life

And develop an overwhelming urge to repay the kindness he’s received

But when he tries to count these blessings, he finds them too numerous and too great —
constant, encompassing, and infinite.

That realization gives birth to a true inner compass:
a sense of obligation, justice, and deep desire to repay good with good.

C. The Collapse of Ego and the Rise of True Service

At this point, a man sees clearly:

He doesn’t have the power to repay God

The Creator doesn’t need him

And his only true position is one of humility and service

He becomes small in his own eyes,
and from that lowliness he begins to rebuild — not in the image of others, but in the image of truth.

He asks:

> “What actions will truly bring me closer to my purpose?”

He no longer acts out of fear of missing out.
He no longer lives to match his neighbor’s car purchase or buy the same type of expensive winter coat for his children.

Instead, he lives to return what is due to G-d, and
his mind guides him along the straight path —
not the herd’s path.

Conclusion: From Sheep to Servant

The follower mentality — that sheep-like tendency to blend in — is not born from stupidity. It’s born from lack of internal order, and most importantly, from confusion about where one stands in the world.

When a person sees only the physical world — the horizontal — and forgets his vertical relationship to Hashem, he becomes reactive, not intentional. A soul that isn’t ruled by truth, justice, and gratitude will be ruled by culture, fashion, and fear.

But a man who builds his world on what God implanted in him — truth, righteousness, discernment, and humility — becomes something far greater than the herd:
He becomes a servant of the King.

Posted in

Leave a comment