Small tidbits and Sparks of wisdom

> “Who turns wise men backward and makes their knowledge foolish.”
— Yeshayahu (Isaiah) 44:25

The destruction of Jewish life has come in waves: through siege and betrayal, fire and sword, Roman brutality and Crusader cruelty. But what ties them together is the tragedy of missed spiritual awareness, leadership dilemmas, and the painful clarity of hindsight. This essay now merges the lessons of Baytar and the Crusades into one long arc of Jewish history — the ongoing struggle between human strategy and Divine Will, between blind zeal and visionary Torah leadership.

—

Chapter 1: Bar Kamtza and the Banquet That Ended a Nation

The narrative begins with Bar Kamtza, a Jew mistakenly invited to a banquet by his enemy. Publicly humiliated and thrown out, Bar Kamtza turned his personal shame into national revenge. He went to the Romans and planted a clever test: a blemished animal sent as a tribute, knowing it would be rejected by halachah.

The Sages debated: allow the offering or uphold the law? But Rabbi Zecharya ben Avkolas refused to allow it. Logic, halachah, and restraint prevailed — and yet it was those very values, taken without the broader picture, that paved the road to destruction.

> “The excessive humility of Rabbi Zecharya ben Avkolas destroyed our Temple, burned our Sanctuary, and exiled us from our land.”
— Rabbi Yoḥanan (Gittin 56a)

—

Chapter 2: Biryonim, Ignorance, and the Siege Within

The Romans outside were not the immediate problem. It was the biryonim — militant, ignorant zealots — who seized control of Jerusalem. They burned food stores, choked the people with famine, and mocked the sages.

They were amei ha’aretz, haters of Torah, intoxicated with false strength. When Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai tried to negotiate peace, they blocked him.

Bruriah’s Model: A Path Not Taken

In Berachos 10a, Rabbi Meir prays for the death of wicked men. His wife, Bruriah, corrects him: _”Pray not for sinners to die, but for sin to vanish.”

He listens. He prays not for destruction but for teshuvah. And it works.

Imagine if the biryonim had been treated that way. If the sages, or even the people, had prayed not for their defeat, but for their transformation. Perhaps they, too, might have become baalei teshuva.

But no such effort is recorded. And the city fell.

Even worse: after the destruction, many of the biryonim remained hardened. They still rejected rabbinic authority. They still did not learn. Their war was not for Hashem. It was a war against wisdom, discipline, and humility.

—

Chapter 3: Baytar and the Price of Misjudged Confidence

After the destruction of Jerusalem came the final blow: the fall of Baytar.

Baytar was strong. It had warriors, a king-like leader, and a proud population. But strength without righteousness is empty.

The Midrash tells of how the leader of Baytar misread a divine sign. He thought his uncle, who bore the signs of mashiach, was a Roman in disguise and killed him. It was a tragic error. Hashem punished Baytar by allowing the Romans to conquer the city.

The slaughter was horrific. So many were killed that their bodies lay unburied for years. And yet, even in that darkness, a miracle occurred: the bodies did not decompose. This is the source of the blessing “HaTov v’HaMeitiv”.

Lesson from Baytar:

Strength must be aligned with Torah values. When people gain power, wealth, and leadership, they must realize: it is only to elevate others toward spiritual greatness. Building homes, armies, or political alliances is not the goal. The goal is Hashem.

—

Chapter 4: The Crusades — Death in Hashem’s Name

Fast forward a thousand years: the Crusades swept across Europe. Jews were slaughtered by the thousands in the name of a false messianic dream — a man on a cross, a sword in his hand.

Entire communities were wiped out. Rhineland towns like Worms, Speyer, and Mainz became killing fields.

And yet, many Jews chose kiddush Hashem — sanctifying G-d’s name through death rather than forced baptism.

The Crusades were not merely political. They were theological: a perverse attempt to eliminate the Jewish witness. Judaism’s very existence disproved Christian claims of replacement and spiritual supremacy.

—

Chapter 5: Divine Will Over Human Logic

Whether it was the fall of Jerusalem, the betrayal at Baytar, or the massacres of the Crusades, one truth shines through:

Even the wisest of men cannot outmaneuver Hashem.

We act with reason, but Hashem has already decided. We plan, but we are walking on the tracks He laid.

> It is not that we gain 20/20 in hindsight. It is that Hashem grants us clarity so we recognize it was always His hand.

—

Chapter 6: When Logic Fails, Faith Must Lead

Rabban Yoḥanan ben Zakkai asked Vespasian only for:

Yavne and its sages

The Davidic line through Rabban Gamliel

Doctors for Rabbi Tzadok

He did not ask to spare Jerusalem.

He was afraid to ask for too much.

Should he have asked for everything? Maybe. The Sages quote Isaiah: _”Who makes wise men foolish.”

But maybe he knew: it was already too late. Hashem had decreed. His job was to preserve a spark.

—

Chapter 7: We Do Not Lead History — We Live It

The mistake is thinking we lead history. That our strategies determine the future.

But Hashem uses even the mistakes of sages and the sins of zealots to carry out His plan.

The challenge is not to become smarter. It is to become more faithful. To act with vision, not just reason. To see from the beginning what Hashem wants, not to look back and say “Ah, now I see.”

And to remember:

It is never too late to pray for someone to change.

Even the biryonim could have become students.

Even Rome could have been softened.

We failed not because we lacked logic. We failed because we lacked the courage to turn ignorance into light, and because we thought we were the ones writing the script.

—

Closing Note:

This combined narrative of Bar Kamtza, Baytar, and the Crusades teaches one unbroken message: history is not ours to command. But our choices within it — to pray, to educate, to unify, and to submit to Torah — are what determine how much of that history is blessed or bitter.

Let us not wait for hindsight to be wise. Let us seek Hashem’s clarity at the beginning.

—