Small tidbits and Sparks of wisdom

The Silence of Leadership:

Devarim 2:16-17 reads:

> “And it came to pass when all the men of war had finished dying from among the people… Hashem spoke to me saying…”

The Sages in Bava Basra 121b derive a striking truth from this verse. For nearly thirty-eight years, Hashem did not speak to Moshe in the same direct, intimate manner as before. Not because Moshe failed, chalilah, but because the people failed—due to the sin of the spies.

The Mechilta and Sifra emphasize that prophecy isn’t merely a private affair between Hashem and the navi. It is a national channel—and when the nation is unworthy, even the greatest leader’s prophecy is affected. Hashem withheld His word not out of Moshe’s personal lacking, but because the nation as a whole was undeserving.

This isn’t just a commentary on Divine communication. It’s a foundational statement about Jewish leadership. Moshe Rabbeinu, the greatest of all prophets, was silenced—because the people he led were not in a state to receive.

One Body, One Soul

This teaches us: leaders and the people are one body. If the “foot” is limping, the “head” feels pain. If the “heart” is corrupted, the “eyes” go dim. Moshe’s silence is not his shame—it is our collective accountability.

We are not a nation of celebrity worship or idolatrous hierarchies. Our leaders are not divine figures—they are mirrors of our potential. If the generation behaves righteously, the leader shines. If the generation fails, the leader is burdened.

As the commentary notes:

> “It was not out of consideration of the personal standing of the prophets, but only for the sake of the nation as a whole… God allowed His Word to come to them, and this was true even in the case of Moshe.”

We Are All Celebrities in Hashem’s Eyes

Torah Judaism does not promote “rockstar” rabbanim or cults of personality. Even the most gifted leader is only elevated for the sake of the klal. And when the klal fails—so too does the leader’s spiritual conduit.

Each of us holds a spark of greatness. Some are blessed with gifts—wisdom, charisma, strength—to lead. But those gifts are not for self-glory. They exist to serve the tzibbur, the way a shepherd serves his flock with love, not superiority.

—

Closing Thought

The Torah’s silence toward Moshe during the midbar years is not a tragedy—it is a wake-up call. When we elevate ourselves, we elevate our leaders. And when we fall, they suffer with us. One nation. One body. One soul.

Let us act in a way that restores the Divine Voice—not just to our prophets, but into the fabric of our daily lives.

—